Mish's Global Economic Trend Analysis

ADP Grossly Overstates Job Growth for Last 12 Months by 419,000 Jobs
Canada GDP "Unexpectedly" Shrinks; Pollyannas Come Out Of Woodwork
"Google Law" Yet Another Warped Policy by Hollande; Government Motors French Style

ADP Grossly Overstates Job Growth for Last 12 Months by 419,000 Jobs

Posted: 31 Oct 2012 02:53 PM PDT

ADP has announced revised methodology to "enhance" its monthly job reports, no doubt because its prior numbers simply were grossly inaccurate.

Indeed, I stopped commenting on ADP numbers because I thought they were absurd.

Let's take a look at their revised methodology. Here is the ADP Jobs Report for September using the revised methodology.

"Private sector employment increased by 88,200 jobs from August to September, according to the September ADP National Employment Report®. The report, which is derived from ADP's actual payroll data, measures the change in total U.S. nonfarm private employment each month on a seasonally adjusted basis. Last month's employment estimate was revised down from 80,000 to 76,400 jobs."

Please note that last sentence. Compare to what ADP actually reported last month:

"Employment in the U.S. nonfarm private business sector increased by 162,000 from August to September, on a seasonally adjusted basis. The estimated gains in previous months were revised lower: The July increase was reduced by 17,000 to an increase of 156,000, while the August increase was reduced by 12,000 to an increase of 189,000."

Got that? September private business sector increased by 162,000 but now we see September was revised down to 76,400 from 80,000 (not 162,000 as actually reported).

Revision Matching

Check out this statement from ADP FAQs.

Using this methodology developed for ADP by Moody's Analytics, our adjusted historical ADP National Employment Report data dating back to 2001 has a 96 percent correlation with the revised BLS numbers.

ADP revisions match BLS revisions over time. Lovely.

Spotlight on Revisions

ZeroHedge totaled up the ADP revisions for 2012 and concluded ADP "Cancels" 365,000 Private Jobs Created In 2012.

I conclude the same thing. However, things are even worse than Zerohedge states. Here is a chart that I put together of ADP revisions.

Note: numbers in charts and tables in thousands.

ADP Original Vs. ADP Revised Monthly Job Gains or Losses

click on chart for sharper image

ADP was way underestimating job gains in 2011 and way over-estimated gains in 2012.

The net effect was 136,000 jobs over 20 months (about 6,800 per month). However that is a very misleading way of looking at things as the following table shows.

Time Period Analysis

Time Period	Cumulative Miss
2011 Miss	229.0
2012 Miss	-365.1
Last 12 Months	-419.1
Since Feb 2011	-136.1

As you can see, I match ZeroHedge for 2012. However, for the last year, ADP was off by an even higher 419,000 jobs, nearly 35,000 jobs a month for an entire year!

For 2011, ADP was off in the other direction by 229,000 jobs, roughly 19,000 per month. Here is the complete table that I worked from.

ADP Data Points Table

Date	ADP Revised	ADP Original	Revision	Cumulative Error
2011-02	155.3	197	-41.7	-41.7
2011-03	215.9	199	16.9	-24.8
2011-04	174.5	162	12.5	-12.3
2011-05	156.4	47	109.4	97.1
2011-06	118.3	136	-17.7	79.5
2011-07	180.3	125	55.3	134.8
2011-08	122.7	67	55.7	190.5
2011-09	197.5	105	92.5	283.0
2011-10	114.3	142	-27.7	255.3
2011-11	173.2	226	-52.8	202.5
2011-12	293.4	267	26.4	229.0
2012-01	218.9	182	36.9	265.8
2012-02	226.6	228	-1.4	264.4
2012-03	89.7	204	-114.3	150.1
2012-04	130.1	112	18.1	168.2
2012-05	81.2	131	-49.8	118.4
2012-06	115.4	173	-57.6	60.8
2012-07	145.5	156	-10.5	50.4
2012-08	76.4	189	-112.6	-62.3
2012-09	88.2	162	-73.8	-136.1

I note with amusement TrimTabs Says BLS Badly Missing Current Acceleration in Job Growth

TrimTabs Investment Research said today that the Bureau of Labor Statistics' (BLS) hefty upward revision of its August job growth estimate proves that the BLS missed the important acceleration in job growth this summer because it relies on incomplete surveys that are frequently revised.

Trimtabs said the BLS' initial estimate for August job growth was 96,000. Today, the BLS revised its August estimate upward 48% to 142,000 new jobs. Meanwhile TrimTabs estimate, based on real-time withholding tax data, said employment growth in August was 185,000.

TrimTabs reported the U.S. economy added 210,000 jobs in September while the BLS reported a job gain of only 114,000. TrimTabs said it expects the BLS to revise its September jobs estimate of 114,000 substantially higher next month.

I did not buy that story then, and I do not buy it now. More than likely, the BLS was catching up to misses earlier in the year, perhaps even 2011 vs. a genuine recent hiring spurt.

Obamacare Employment Analysis

I am sticking to what I said regarding Obamacare, especially Obama Slashes Four Hours Off Definition of "Full-Time" Employment

Additional Obamacare Employment Analysis

By the way, these ADP revisions suggest the stated unemployment rate is blatantly preposterous, something I say in every jobs report.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com

"Wine Country" Economic Conference Hosted By Mish
Click on Image to Learn More

Canada GDP "Unexpectedly" Shrinks; Pollyannas Come Out Of Woodwork

Posted: 31 Oct 2012 11:21 AM PDT

Economists who cannot see anything but the rear view mirror were surprised to learn Canadian Economy Shrinks as Oil, Mining Slump.

The Canadian economy shrank unexpectedly in August, pointing to a sharp third-quarter slowdown in growth from the first half and reinforcing the Bank of Canada's message that interest rate hikes are less imminent.

The surprising 0.1 percent contraction in August from July reflected broad weakness across most industries, prompting economists to revise forecasts down. The Canadian dollar weakened to below parity with its U.S. counterpart.

August's dip was the first monthly contraction in GDP since February. Statistics Canada said on Wednesday it was largely caused by decreased production in the natural resources sector - oil and gas extraction and mining - as well as in manufacturing,

Statscan said temporary maintenance work at some mines and oilfields was partly to blame. But some economists argued that the economy had stalled more broadly.

"There are too many negatives in this report to dismiss the headline weakness as being attributable to just temporary disruptions in some sectors," said Derek Holt and Dov Zigler of Scotia Capital.

Doug Porter, deputy chief economist at BMO Capital Markets, noted that output fell in 10 of 18 sectors. "We can't brush this off as driven by special factors," he said.

Flaherty was more sanguine. "We're going to see some variations, but overall, for the year we are on track with GDP growth," he told reporters.

Flaherty expects 2.1 percent growth this year, based on the average forecast of private sector economists his office surveyed this month.

The Bank of Canada has also suggested the third quarter was an anomaly. Last week it halved its forecast for third-quarter growth to an annualized 1 percent, but predicted a rebound to 2.5 percent growth in the fourth quarter and average growth of more than 2 percent through 2014.

Pollyannas Come Out Of Woodwork

BMO and Scotia Capital analysts may be late to the recession party (or not, I do not know previous calls), but otherwise, Pollyannas like Jim Flaherty, Canada's Finance Minister, and officials at the Bank of Canada and Statscan are still looking for growth.

Forget about it. This is not an anomaly as suggested by the Bank of Canada.

As I have said repeatedly, the slowdown in Asia is going to hit Canadian commodity producers more than most think. Moreover, signs suggest Canada's long overdue housing bust is finally underway according to the Canadian Real Estate Association Report on October 15.

Here is the key item: Actual (not seasonally adjusted) activity is down 15.1 % from year-ago levels, with more than half of all local markets posting declines of at least 10 per cent.

The rest of the report staked out a claim that real estate was "balanced", I maintain in the same way that spinning plates in this video can be stated as balanced.

With the US economy slowing, with Asia slowing, and with Europe in a full-blown recession, the odds of Canada and the US bucking the trend is essentially zero.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com

"Google Law" Yet Another Warped Policy by Hollande; Government Motors French Style

Posted: 31 Oct 2012 09:14 AM PDT

French president François Hollande took two more swan dives into the pool of ludicrous actions in the past few days, first with car-maker Peugeot, quickly followed up with a guaranteed-to-fail proposal regarding search engine giant Google.

Government Motors French Style

Bloomberg reports France Guarantees Peugeot Debt in Exchange for Influence

The French government stepped in to rescue PSA Peugeot Citroen (UG), Europe's second-largest carmaker, by guaranteeing as much as 7 billion euros ($9 billion) in new bonds in exchange for greater influence over company strategy.

The state and workers will each receive a seat on the board of directors, and an outside committee will be set up with veto power over any "significant" changes in Peugeot's operations, the French Finance Ministry said today.

"The state will want to see this business run more in the interest of government, rather than in the interest of the shareholders," said Erich Hauser, a Credit Suisse analyst with a neutral rating on the shares. "The rising debt of Peugeot clearly shows that the core things are getting worse."

Sheer Madness

I would like to point out how ridiculous this action is, but Pater Tenebrarum at the Acting Man blog beat me to it. He did a first-class job of making Hollande look foolish in his post Peugeot Bailed Out, More Trouble for the Banks.

The government and workers will receive board seats? Are they sure this is going to work out? We believe that this latest socialistic experiment is highly likely to turn into a bottomless pit for France's tax payers.

Not surprisingly, competing car makers in other European countries are rather unhappy that an inefficient competitor is kept on artificial life support. They are perfectly right to complain. To keep companies that are not competitive artificially afloat harms the economy at large, but it is especially detrimental to more able companies in the same branch of industry.

However, the French government insists that it is actually not providing aid to Peugeot, and will therefore not run afoul of EU regulations that forbid such state aid. It is not giving aid, it is merely providing 'support'.

Hang on, it gets even better. Guess who Peugeot is now in an alliance with to produce new cars consumers will – hopefully – want? You guessed it…. GM, the original 'government motors': Peugeot said today it's making progress with GM on the alliance and the two have selected four vehicle projects to work on together.

"Google Law" Another Sign of Hollande's Warped Mind

That piece by Tenebrarum is a tough act to follow. Nonetheless, please consider the Wall Street Journal article France Calls On Google to Settle Rift With Publishers

France will consider adopting legislation that would force Google Inc. GOOG to pay for the right to cite news articles online if the U.S. search giant fails to settle a long-running dispute with French news publishers over how to share advertising revenue, the office of France's President François Hollande said on Monday.

Mr. Hollande's ultimatum marks an escalation in the protracted battle pitting news publishers against Google, which has long resisted the idea of sharing ad revenue with content providers.

Google has warned it would exclude French newspapers from its search engine if France implements the proposed law, which would make search engines pay for the right to cite news online.

Leading French newspaper publishers last month called on the government to adopt legislation imposing a settlement in their dispute with Google, forcing it and other search engines to share some of the advertising revenue. Their request follows the German government's approval of draft legislation in August that would force search engines to pay commissions to German media websites.

The new law—sometimes dubbed the "Google law"—has been pitched by French newspapers as a means to help support their business, which is under threat from a long-term migration of advertising away from print media, a trend exacerbated by cuts in advertising as the French economy struggles.

Do A Search For Anything

Just so you know what we are talking about here, please do a Google search for anything. Hurricane Sandy is as good a topic as any.

Here is an image of the results.

Imagine Boston.Com, Bloomberg, the Washington Post, and the Weather Channel all demanding Google share add revenue with them for any ad that appears in those search results.

While you are at it, imagine me demanding ad revenue sharing for those doing a Google search for Mish. Many people find me that way. "Mish" is my brand, and I appear at the top of any such search.

Here is an image of a search for Mish.

Instead of getting some ad revenue when people click on links to French news articles, there will be no links to click on at all if Hollande does what he says (and Google responds the way they have said).

Hollande wants to help struggling newspapers, struggling car makers, struggling students, all with ludicrous actions on top of massive tax hikes. He even wants to ban homework because "It's Not Fair to Disadvantaged".

On June 8, I reported Hollande About to Wreck France With Economically Insane Proposal: "Make Layoffs So Expensive For Companies That It's Not Worth It"

It should be easy enough to guess the company that triggered that last bit of layoff-insanity, but in case you misplaced your thinking cap, the answer is Peugeot.

Prepare for the implosion of France, because it is nearly certain with Hollande at the helm.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com

"Wine Country" Economic Conference Hosted By Mish
Click on Image to Learn More

Home Refinance Calculator

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

Mish's Global Economic Trend Analysis

Mish's Global Economic Trend Analysis

No comments:

Post a Comment