Mish's Global Economic Trend Analysis |
- "Wall Street is Little More than Glorified Crack House"; ECRI Sticks with US Recession Call; So Does John Hussman, with Odds Above 80%; So Do I; SF Fed has 50-50 Odds
- US Petroleum and Gasoline Usage Plunges Last 5 Weeks Compared to Prior Years
- Monetary Flight; European CEOs Move Cash to Germany; Spanish Companies Expect Return to Peseta; Expect Capital Controls
- Cameron Finally Tells Sarkozy Where to Go; New treaty Splits European Union; Extreme Legal Complications Already; Expect Discord to Rapidly Spread
- Moody's Downgrades French Banks Again Citing Significant Deterioration in Liquidity and Funding Conditions; EU Banks Must Raise $153 Billion of Extra Capital; Banks Running to Stand Still
Posted: 09 Dec 2011 11:05 AM PST Lakshman Achuthan, chief operations officer of the Economic Cycle Research Institute (ECRI), talks about the U.S. economy and his recession call with Tom Keene on Bloomberg Television. ECRI Sticks with US Recession Call Link if video does not play: U.S. Economic Outlook, Labor Market Partial Transcript Keene: You had a recession call. What happened? Achuthan: It's happening. Keene: Too many economists are talking 3% GDP. Achuthan: First off, I talked to you September 30th right here. I made the recession call, two months ago. A lot of economists since then, as they always do are focused on incoming data, a lot of which is coincident or short-leading, and indeed there absolutely has been stronger coincident and short-leading data. ... What we have learned from that is the recession did not begin in Q3. I do not know about Q4. Keene: Amateurs look at the timing of the call. The pros look at the vector or direction of the call. You maintain the direction of the call. Achuthan: We have not switched our call. If there is no recession in Q4 or first half of 2012 then we are wrong. You will not even know if we are wrong until a year from now. ..... So far we are talking about coincident data, production and jobs. Forward looking data since I saw you two months ago has remained weak, and is getting weaker. To my fellow forecasters out there, I'd say they are roughly in two camps. There are those who say the economy is firming and will continue to firm into next year. We reject that. There is nothing here to suggest that at all. There is a larger camp that says we are going to "muddle through" with slow growth. I would point out that has never happened. We never "muddle through". ECRI Has This One Nailed I think Achuthan and the ECRI have this forecast nailed. My problem with the ECRI is two-fold.
Problem number one is easily explained. The ECRI sells a service and it does not want anyone figuring out precisely what it is doing. Problem number two is serious. The ECRI claims its WLI has never missed a recession call. However, the facts show the ECRI has indeed blown recession calls and its own commentary proves it. Please consider some excerpts from ECRI's Lakshman Achuthan Still Blowing Smoke Note this statement by Achuthan to the Wall Street Journal. Next, please consider some charts and text from the ECRI publication The Great Recession and Recovery ECRI Weekly Leading IndexGot That? Look at that last panel carefully. The ECRI claims the WLI "has correctly predicted every recession in real time" while also stating "ECRI itself has never used WLI growth going negative as as a recession signal." But wait. There's still more ECRI hypocrisy. Flashback November 2007 ECRI Vol. XII, No. 11: Weakness In Leading Indicators Not Yet Recessionary Please consider the following image snip. Highlighting is mine. The ECRI persisted for months the recession was avoidable. In January 2008 the ECRI said there was a "window of opportunity". In March of 2008, months after the recession started, the ECRI finally threw in the towel and relented, calling it a "recession of choice". Please see A Look at ECRI's Recession Predicting Track Record for numerous details. The idea the US could have prevented a recession in January of 2008, as the ECRI claimed is stunningly preposterous, as is the ECRI lie that the WLI has a perfect track record. ECRI Track Record is NOT perfect As I said (and more importantly have proven), the ECRI's track record is not perfect. Nor is mine or anyone else's. All Achuthan needs to do is stop pretending the ECRI is perfect, and I will stop bringing this matter up. That said, I will reiterate that it is highly likely the " ECRI has this forecast nailed". Moreover, John Hussman at Hussman Funds agrees. Estimated Probability of Recession Over 80% On December 4, in Have We Avoided A Recession? Hussman takes a crack at predicting the odds of recession. In recent months, we've observed a fairly neutral flow of economic data - not strong by any means, but offering a reprieve from the clearly negative momentum that we observed in late-summer. ..."Wall Street is Little More than Glorified Crack House" My favorite part of the article is not the recession prediction odds but Hussman's accurate rant at the end. We represent the Lollipop GuildSan Francisco Fed Calculates 50% Chance of Recession In yet one more look at recession chances, please consider Future Recession Risks: An Update by the San Francisco Fed. Gathering storms across the Atlantic threaten a U.S. economy not yet recovered from the last recession. The September Economic Outlook from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) indicates that growth prospects have significantly dimmed for major industrialized economies (OECD 2011). Growth in the G-7 countries is expected to remain below 1% for the rest of the year, while the odds of a contraction are fifty-fifty.San Francisco Fed Understates Problems in US and Europe I believe the San Francisco Fed significantly understates the problems in the US economy. Moreover, the SF Fed even more seriously understates the problems in Europe. Finally the SF Fed does not address the numerous problems in China at all. Europe is in recession right here right now. That European recession probability approaches 100% in my opinion. Worse yet, various austerity measures imposed on numerous European countries ensures the recession will be long and deep. Numerous tax hikes in Italy, Europe's third largest economy compound the problem greatly. For a few details of Europe's problems please see ...
The China Factor China's manufacturing PMI plunged to a 32-month low of 47.7 and is in contraction. China's real estate sector is in shambles. Chinese demand for commodities will drop, putting pressure on exporters like Australia and Canada. Global trade will suffer. In short, the ECRI Sticks with its US Recession Call, So Does John Hussman, and so do I for numerous US and global reasons. Mike "Mish" Shedlock http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List |
US Petroleum and Gasoline Usage Plunges Last 5 Weeks Compared to Prior Years Posted: 09 Dec 2011 09:04 AM PST Here is a set of charts from reader Tim Wallace on Gasoline and Petroleum usage vs. the same five weeks in prior years. Explanations from Wallace follow each chart. click on any chart for sharper image Petroleum Usage Petroleum usage history for the past 6 years for this 5 week snapshot - you can see the drop from '06 to '07 was small but I caught that trend in Oct of '07 and got out of the market. My experience suggests that if petroleum does not grow at least 0.8% year on year the economy is headed recessionary. Notice the plunge of '08 into the abyss of '09. We see a good improvement in 2010, not anywhere near the recovery we need as we were in an abyss, but it shows improvement. This year, we see another significant downturn, reflective of a stalled at-bet economy. Gasoline Usage Gasoline usage history shows a small rise in '07, then a plunge in '08. Usage level for the next two years was flat, followed by a huge plunge now. I did not expect this plunge because gasoline is a lot less volatile in my historical analysis than the overall distillates, some of which are weather related, such as heating oil. It raises the question, why have people stopping driving, because that is what is happening. Fuel Distillates Usage The third chart shows the fuel distillates usage. This is the diesel, heating oil segment combined. Diesel makes up 17% of all petroleum and heating oil 3%. Much of the driver in the petroleum usage drop in '08 and '09 came from this segment of the economy. The current drop is due to a huge plunge in gasoline usage. Percent Change from 2006 Baseline The final chart shows the percentage changes in the past five years off the 2006 baseline. You can see gasoline at about 46% of distillates usage is the driver for the big drop in petroleum right now. Cash-for-Clunkers Mileage Improvement Not the Explanation for Gasoline Plunge Please see Crude Futures Have Risen Significantly, So Why are Gasoline Prices Relatively Low? for additional commentary and a rebuttal to the idea that improved mileage or cash-for-clunkers may have anything to do with the current decline in gasoline usage. The best explanation for declining gasoline usage is that millions have dropped out of the labor force. Quick Facts on Unemployment Rate
Please see Charts of the Day: Labor Force and Unemployment Rate Adjusted for Population Growth Since 1948 Show Falling Unemployment Rate is "Statistical Mirage" for details and charts. People have given up looking for work, entered forced retirement collecting social security, ran out of unemployment benefits, do more shopping online, or are simply too broke (or have less desire) to travel than before. Mike "Mish" Shedlock http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List |
Posted: 09 Dec 2011 08:58 AM PST Bloomberg reports European CEOs Move Cash to Germany Grupo Gowex (GOW), a Spanish provider of Wi-Fi wireless services, is moving funds to Germany because it expects Spain to exit the euro. German machinery maker GEA Group AG is setting maximum amounts held at any one bank.Expect Capital Controls As I said in regards to Greece, the sane thing to do is get your money out of any troubled countries. If everyone does the sane thing, it will bring the crisis to a head quicker. In response, expect countries to impose capital controls. Mike "Mish" Shedlock http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List |
Posted: 09 Dec 2011 02:00 AM PST UK prime minister David Cameron was ready to sign on the Merkozy treaty dotted line if he got exceptions to some UK-unfriendly rules. When Sarkozy refused to go along, the two got into a nice verbal feud, and Cameron finally said what he should have said months if not years ago as reported by Yahoo!Finance in New treaty Splits European Union "What was on offer is not in Britain's interest so I didn't agree to it," he told reporters in Brussels.Now, what's so hard about that? Cameron's next move should be to tell the EU to take all of their rules and shove them too. Hungary Opts Out, So will Sweden, Czech Republic Undecided Swedish Prime Minister Fredrik Reinfeldt signaled after the meeting it was unlikely his country would join the accord.Extreme Legal Complications Already Via Google Translate please consider this snip from Spiegel Online The new agreement between the 23 EU countries, according to experts, however, could lead to numerous legal problems, because the rules must not contradict rules of the EU treaties.Expect Discord to Rapidly Spread The simple solution to Cameron's legal problem is for the UK (and any other country with the same objection) to leave the EU. All it would take is a voter referendum. Meanwhile, the discord between Cameron and Sarkozy is going to quickly spread elsewhere. The more details this new treaty adds, the more discord there will be. The entire package will blow up in May (if not long before that) if any country or the German supreme court insists on a voter referendum. Mike "Mish" Shedlock http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List |
Posted: 09 Dec 2011 12:45 AM PST Moody's downgraded Credit Agricole, BNP Paribas, and Societe Generale today. This is fresh on the heels of a September downgrade of Credit Agricole and Societe Generale in September. Please consider French bank ratings downgraded again by Moody's Credit rating agency Moody's has downgraded France's three big banks due to their difficulty borrowing money. The agency cut Credit Agricole and BNP Paribas from Aa2 to Aa3, and Societe Generale from Aa3 to A1.Banks Running to Stand Still Bloomberg reports EU Banks Must Raise $153 Billion of Extra Capital European Union banks must raise 114.7 billion euros ($152.8 billion) in fresh capital as part of measures introduced to respond to the euro area's sovereign-debt crisis.Bank of France debts jump tenfold on capital flight For more on the liquidity issues facing French banks, please consider Bank of France debts jump tenfold on capital flight by Ambrose Evans-Pritchard. French lenders lost €100bn (£86bn) in short-term deposits in September alone, mostly due to precautionary moves by US money market funds and Asian investors afraid of France's exposure to Italy. "There were huge net capital outflows," said Eric Dor from the IESEG School of Management in Lille. Desperate Times Lead to Desperate Lies Flashback September 25, 2011: Desperate Times Lead to Desperate Lies Check out these preposterous lies by Bank of France Governor Christian Noyer as quoted by Bloomberg in Noyer Sees 'Absolutely No Reason' to Use Bank BackstopDexia Bank Blows Up October 3 Two refresh your memory, less than two weeks after Bank of France Governor Christian Noyer made his preposterous statements, Dexia, a combined Belgian-French bank went under. Please see Dexia, Belgium's Largest Lender About to Become First Casualty of Greek Default; Emergency Meeting to Split Bank Now in Progress. Difficult to Believe Anything The lies are so blatant now, it is difficult to believe anything a bank says, an EU official says, the IMF says, or the EMU says. I remind you of the admitted policy of Jean-Claude Juncker, the prime minister of Luxembourg and chairman of the eurozone finance ministers: "When it becomes serious, you have to lie". Given that things are nearly always serious, the safe thing to do is not believe anything, especially in regards to solvency issues, capitalization needs, and liquidity problem denials. I have a big hint for all these eurocratic and central bank liars: If you want to restore confidence, the first thing you have to do is tell the truth. Mike "Mish" Shedlock http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List |
You are subscribed to email updates from Mish's Global Economic Trend Analysis To stop receiving these emails, you may unsubscribe now. | Email delivery powered by Google |
Google Inc., 20 West Kinzie, Chicago IL USA 60610 |
No comments:
Post a Comment